Thousands of chemical substances are made in, imported into, or used in Canada, in products that range from industrial solvents to furniture foam and food packaging. The question of which ones are safe enough to stay on the market, and which need limits, falls largely to one federal statute: the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999, usually shortened to CEPA. The law is jointly administered by the Minister of Environment and Climate Change and the Minister of Health, and it sets out a structured path from scientific assessment to legal control.
Two Streams: Existing and New Substances
CEPA treats chemicals differently depending on whether they were already in Canadian commerce when the modern regime took shape.
- Existing substances appear on the Domestic Substances List, an inventory of roughly 23,000 substances that were in use in Canada in the mid 1980s, plus those added since. These can stay on the market while government scientists work through them.
- New substances are those not on the list. A company that wants to manufacture or import one must first notify the federal government and supply prescribed data. Officials then assess the substance before it enters the market, and they can impose conditions or prohibit it if they suspect a risk.
This split explains why so much federal effort has gone into existing chemicals. They were grandfathered in without a modern review, so the government had to sort through the backlog. A categorization exercise completed in 2006 identified about 4,300 substances as priorities for further attention, and the Chemicals Management Plan was launched that year to work through them.
What “Toxic” Means in Law
The word has a specific legal meaning under CEPA that differs from everyday usage. Under section 64 of the Act, a substance is toxic if it is entering or may enter the environment in a quantity, concentration, or under conditions that:
- have or may have an immediate or long term harmful effect on the environment or its biological diversity;
- constitute or may constitute a danger to the environment on which life depends; or
- constitute or may constitute a danger in Canada to human life or health.
Two points follow from this wording. First, the test is based on risk, which combines how hazardous a substance is with how much exposure actually occurs. A hazardous chemical used in tiny, contained quantities may not meet the test, while a less hazardous one released widely might. Second, the phrase “may have” allows the ministers to act on a reasonable prospect of harm instead of waiting for proof of damage. The Act also directs the government to apply the precautionary principle and a weight of evidence approach.
From Screening to Regulation
The path from scientific concern to legal control follows a fairly consistent sequence.
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| Information gathering | Officials collect data on uses, volumes, and releases, sometimes through mandatory surveys issued to industry. |
| Draft assessment | Environment and Climate Change Canada and Health Canada publish a draft screening assessment with a proposed conclusion, followed by a public comment period. |
| Final assessment | The ministers publish a final conclusion on whether the substance meets a section 64 criterion. |
| Listing | If the substance is found toxic, the ministers may recommend adding it to Schedule 1 of the Act, which the federal cabinet does by order. |
| Risk management | The government proposes and then finalizes a control instrument, within timelines set out in the Act. |
Listing on Schedule 1 does not ban anything by itself. Its effect is to unlock the authority to regulate. The actual restrictions come from whichever instrument is chosen afterward.
The Risk Management Toolbox
CEPA offers several instruments, and the choice depends on how serious the risk is and where it arises:
- Regulations that prohibit or limit manufacture, import, use, sale, or release.
- Pollution prevention planning notices that require specified facilities to prepare and implement plans to reduce a substance.
- Codes of practice and guidelines that set recommended practices without the force of regulation.
- Significant New Activity provisions that require a company to notify the government before using a substance in a new way, so the new use can be assessed first.
Tracking also matters. Many substances managed under CEPA are reported each year by industrial facilities through the National Pollutant Release Inventory, which gives regulators and the public a view of whether releases are actually falling.
What Changed With the 2023 Amendments
CEPA went more than two decades without a major overhaul. That changed in June 2023, when Parliament passed Bill S-5, the Strengthening Environmental Protection for a Healthier Canada Act. Several of its changes bear directly on chemicals:
- A right to a healthy environment. The Act now recognizes that every individual in Canada has this right as provided under CEPA, and it requires the government to develop a framework explaining how the right will be considered in administering the law.
- A two part Schedule 1. Substances that pose the highest risk are placed in Part 1, where prohibition is to be given priority when choosing controls. Other toxic substances go in Part 2, where pollution prevention is the priority.
- A plan of priorities. The ministers must publish a plan setting out which substances will be assessed and managed, replacing the reliance on the original 2006 list.
- Vulnerable populations and cumulative effects. Assessments must consider groups that may be more exposed or more susceptible, as well as the combined effects of exposure to multiple substances, where information is available.
- A Watch List. The government can publish a list of substances that do not currently meet the toxic test but could if, for example, their use increased.
Details on how these provisions are being implemented are published through the federal CEPA Registry, which also hosts notices, proposed regulations, and consultation documents.
Limits and Ongoing Debates
The system has drawn criticism from different directions. Health and environmental groups have long argued that assessments take too long and that a substance by substance approach invites companies to swap a restricted chemical for a close relative that has not yet been reviewed. Assessing chemicals as classes, as the federal government has moved to do for some groups, is one response to that concern.
Industry groups have raised a different worry: that the label “toxic” can stigmatize materials that are safe in most uses, and that listing decisions should be tightly tied to demonstrated exposure. Because the federal power to regulate toxic substances rests on the criminal law power under the Constitution, listing decisions can also be tested in court.
Jurisdiction adds another layer. CEPA governs the chemicals themselves, but provinces regulate much of what happens at individual facilities, including permits for discharges to air and water. That shared arrangement is similar to the one behind Canada’s air quality standards, where federal objectives depend heavily on provincial implementation.
How to Follow a Substance
Anyone can check where a particular chemical stands. The federal chemical substances website lists assessment status by substance name and by Chemical Abstracts Service registry number, and draft assessments are open for public comment when they are published in the Canada Gazette. For readers concerned about a specific product ingredient, the final screening assessment is usually the most useful document, because it explains both the hazard findings and the exposure assumptions behind the conclusion.
References
- Government of Canada. Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999. Justice Laws Website.
- Environment and Climate Change Canada. Domestic Substances List. CEPA Registry.
- Health Canada. Chemicals Management Plan. Government of Canada.
- Environment and Climate Change Canada. Toxic Substances List: Schedule 1. CEPA Registry.
- Environment and Climate Change Canada. Canadian Environmental Protection Act Registry. Government of Canada.